Why donor countries are giving less to the Palestinians?

Why donor countries are giving less to the Palestinians

On Jan. 12, 2010, US Middle East Envoy George Mitchell, Norway’s Foreign Minister Jonas Gahr Store and EU High Representative for Foreign Affairs Catherine Ashton (L-R) address a joint news conference at the end of an informal meeting regarding donor assistance to the Palestinian Authority in Brussels.(photo byREUTERS/Thierry Roge)

Why donor countries are giving less to the Palestinians

When the Palestinian Authoritywas established in 1994 pursuant to the 1993 Oslo Accord, the international community undertook to provide it with financial and economic support, amounting to $17 billion since its establishment until today. Most of this support was earmarked for bolstering thePalestinian governments budget that was primarily used to pay the wages of PA employees, whose numbers exceed 180,000 today, more than 20 years following the establishment of the PA.

However, Palestinian Prime Minister Rami Hamdallah announced Feb. 16 thatin 2015, the PA receivedhalf the usual aid pledged by donor countries. There has been a sharp decline in foreign assistance, which typicallymakes up37% of the Palestinian general budget. Meanwhile, the remaining funds come inthrough local tax revenues and customs fees tothe Israeli side, according toa financial reportissued by the Palestine Economic Policy Research Institute-MASin January 2016.

Palestinian Finance Minister Shukri Bishara said in a Feb. 2 statement that foreign support for the PA has been going downhill. Between 2007 and 2012, this aid amounted to approximately $1.2 billion, decreasing by $200 million between 2013 and 2014.

Bishara explained that foreign aid to the PA witnessed anothersharp dropto less than $800 million in 2015. He saidSaudi Arabia was the most committed donor among Arab countries, providing aid totaling $241.6 million, followed by Algeria with $52.8 million,while the United Arab Emirates, Qatar, the United States and the World Bank failedto contribute any funds to the Palestinian budget in 2015.

Al-Monitor reviewed the reports of the Palestinian general budget for 2016,which showed that the PA received no morethan $750 million in foreignaid in 2015.

Former Palestinian Minister of Planning and Labor Samir Abdullah told Al-Monitor, The PA is not facing an international decision to completely halt assistance. The stoppage was gradual, as donor countries reduced their aid by a certain percentage every year. The United States, for example, cut aid from $400 million per year to almost zero, and the $500 million per year that Arab countries previously paiddeclined to only $150 million,while the European Union donated between 500 and 600 million euros [$550-$660 million], which declined to 300 million euros [$330 million].

It should be noted that these figures are approximateas they change every year according to the donor’sabilities.

Declining international support to the PA coincided with reduced international interest in the Palestinian cause, as international decision-makers grew more concerned about other issuessuch as Syria, Iraq, Yemen, and the influx of hundreds of thousands of Syrian and Iraqi refugees to European countries.

Samir Abdullah, the former minister of planning and of labor,said,International support for the PA has declined despite the fact that the Palestinian cause and the Palestinian-Israeli conflict may seem more important, from a strategic point of view, to the great powers of the world.

On Jan. 18, the PA declared that the 2016 budget amounted to $4.25 billion, and estimated that its total revenues would exceed $2 billion, collected as taxes, revenue transfers from Israeland foreign aid.

Nasr Abdul Kareem, a professor of economics at Birzeit University in the West Bank, told Al-Monitor, The financial crisis suffered by the PA due to a decline of international aid is not new, but has been ongoing since itsinception. The PAis almost entirely reliant on foreign aid, and its budgetshave experienced deficits for the past 15 years. Butthis time around, the decline is linked to the existing confrontation between Palestinians and Israelis, and the lack of any forthcoming solutions thereto, which might lead to a stifling financial liquidity crisis for the PA. It should be noted that the EU has been the PAs main financier for years, paying 45% of all regular financial assistance.

The PA is fully aware that international aid is not free, but contingent on maintaining the viability of the peace process between the PA and Israel.European taxpayers must beconvinced to continue providing aid to the Palestinians. As such, the aid may be further diminished if the peace process were to come to a complete halt.

Yet thissituation may be preceded by European efforts to exhaust all political options between Palestinians and Israelisbefore announcing a complete halt to the peace processand consequently an end to aid provided to the PA. On Feb. 19, France announced it will hosta summit between Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu in July, in an attempt to revive the peace process and resume negotiations that have been stalled since April 2014.

A European diplomatvisitingGazatold Al-Monitor on condition of anonymity, The EU may cease its financial aid to the PAin light of the worsening political situation between the Palestinians and Israelisand the lack of a negotiated political process between them. For the EU will not disburse free moneyin the absence of a peace process that achieves political and security stability in the Palestinian territories, as said peace process is the basis upon which European aid has been predicated since the establishment of the PA.

The World Bank announcedFeb. 12 that the PAs financial situation was difficultand its economic recovery was slowdue to a 60% decline of donor aid, theresult ofthe lack of progress in peace talks between Palestinians and Israelis. On that same date, the International Monetary Fundalso announced that foreign aid to the PA had shrunk from $2.7 billion in 2008 to less than$800 million in 2015.

Omar Shaban, the director of Pal-Think for Strategic Studies in Gaza, told Al-Monitor, The EU was no longer desirous of continuing to pay the wages of the PAs 70,000 employees in Gaza, who, pursuant to instructions by the PA, no longer reported for work in Gazaafter Hamas takeover of the Strip in mid-2007. These developments came in conjunction with a general reduction of financial aid provided to the PA, particularly by European countries such as Belgium and the Netherlands. [This reduction] was due to the financialpressures faced by the EU caused by the influx of hundreds of thousands of refugees from Syria and Iraq in past months.

On Sept. 29, the World Bank expressed concernthat the continued decline of international assistance to the PA would cause instability and political conflict. Ifa Palestinian statefailsto emerge, stuck inapolitical dead-end with Israel,theninternational decision-makers will find it difficult to convince their constituents of the need to continue financing the PA, leading to the latters gradual inability to carry out its duties, services and administrative responsibilities tothe Palestinian populace andits ultimate collapse.


Check Also

Walking 2,000 miles in solidarity with the Palestinians

Walking 2,000 miles in solidarity with the Palestinians

Walkers plan to enter Jerusalem on 2 November to mark the centenary of the Balfour …

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *